Rose’s Dilemma

Rose Steiner’s life is haunted by the memory of her dead lover, acclaimed author Walsh McLaren. Unable to let go, she herself has been unable to write a novel in five years. Stagnating under the burden of grief, she continues to communicate with her soulmate. It is during this time that McLaren urges his beloved to finish his last book, thereby avoiding bankruptcy.

Lyn Wilson gives a layered performance as Rose. Her sense of longing is felt throughout the play, allowing the audience to empathise with her dilemma. Andrew Horwood cuts a menacing figure as he too struggles with letting go. Chemistry is essential between these former lovers and they deliver in spades.

Rounding out the cast are Laura Antoniazzi and Simon Lancione, who play Arlene Moss and Gavin Clancy respectively. Clancy is introduced into the plot when Rose needs help to finish Walsh’s book. Having had limited success with his own writing endeavours, Lancione brings a brash freshness to the story. Antoniazzi’s naïve charm is a lovely contrast to the solemn delivery of her mentor Rose.

Mary-Jane Minear has designed a stunning and workable set, giving the actors space to move in a realistic and aesthetically pleasing manner. Set in The Hamptons, you can almost feel the breeze from the deck overlooking the water.

Brian Godfrey has chosen one of playwright Neil Simon’s lesser known works for his directing debut at St Judes. His direction is artistic and thoughtful. Illuminating the pathos, he is successful in eliciting an appropriate response from the audience. Backed by a wonderful creative team, this local theatre group has served up another fabulous and thoughtful night at the theatre.

Kerry Cooper