The Mirror Crack’d
There’s something quite radical about staging Agatha Christie in 2026 and trusting the audience to sit still and listen. Centenary Theatre Group’s production of The Mirror Crack’d, adapted for the stage by Rachel Wagstaff and directed by Alison Lees, draws the audience into an evening of attentive listening and shared sleuthing alongside Jane Marple, demonstrating that genuine suspense arises not from spectacle, but from language, restraint and the gradual tightening of narrative tension.
Christie’s 1962 novel sits at an intriguing cultural crossroads. Set in the shifting social landscape of post-war England, it captures the moment when traditional village life begins to collide with celebrity culture and suburban expansion. The arrival of a glamorous American film star in St Mary Mead is not simply a plot device. It is a metaphor for a world recalibrating its values. Miss Marple, ageing and physically confined after an accident, becomes both observer and moral barometer in a society learning to live with modernity’s changes.
This is a dialogue-heavy work. Christie’s plotting demands attentive audiences and disciplined performers, and that demand is palpable. At times, the density of text proved a challenge. A few memory lapses were deftly improvised around, but they occasionally disrupted pacing and the cumulative rhythm that’s vital to a mystery. Similarly, some accents wavered, slipping in and out of place. In a piece so reliant on linguistic precision, consistency of voice becomes part of the architecture. These are refinements rather than flaws, and tightening them would elevate an already engaging production.
The ensemble is well cast and clearly collaborative. There is a shared understanding of tone, particularly in the balancing act between wit and menace. Dana Stolp’s Cherry Baker is grounded and believable, resisting caricature and offering a refreshingly natural presence. Desley Nichols brings to Jane Marple a clarity of diction and a finely tuned economy of expression. Her facial work in particular carries the intellectual labour of the role. Much of Marple’s investigation happens in silence, and Nichols allows thought to register before speech. It is a performance that honours Christie’s most enduring sleuth.
Erik de Wit’s CI Dermot Craddock is neatly characterised, his measured delivery lending authority without bluster. Keith Scrivens as Cyril Leigh demonstrates excellent comic timing, mining the text for humour without fracturing the play’s tonal integrity. Natalie Pedler, Traci Sumpter and Trevor Bond each display sharp characterisation and an instinct for comic inflection, ensuring that the village never tips into blandness. As the film star Marina Gregg, Selina Kadell offers charisma and strong physical storytelling. She understands that celebrity in this context is both armour and vulnerability, and she plays the duality with conviction.
Alison Lees’ direction shows a keen sense of narrative clarity. The red herrings are planted with care. We, the audience, think we’ve worked it out and then more red herrings emerge. The pleasure of misdirection is alive and well here. My favourite aspect of the show was precisely that guessing game, the quiet thrill of assembling and reassembling the evidence in one’s mind.
Visually, the production is thoughtfully realised. The set largely supports the era and social milieu, although the two long benches placed across the front of the stage felt at odds with the rest of the design. While undoubtedly a versatile solution, they visually truncated the playing space and slightly disrupted the illusion of period authenticity established elsewhere. A small adjustment in that configuration could restore a stronger sense of spatial coherence.
Julie Collins’ digital projections are used with sophistication. The evocation of television screens and the strategic deployment of images of Marina Gregg deepen the thematic exploration of fame and mediated identity. Serena Altea’s wardrobe is a standout. Each character is clearly delineated through costume, and the period silhouettes are handled with care. The actors inhabit their clothing comfortably, which in turn supports characterisation. It may seem a minor detail, but the props too are commendably chosen and handled, contributing quietly but effectively to the world building.
Centenary Theatre Group’s season demonstrates that community theatre, when treated with seriousness of craft, can engage robustly with classic material. There is discipline here, humour, and a genuine respect for the text. With minor tightening the production could sharpen its already strong impact.
In an era saturated with fast content and fragmented attention, this staging asks us to lean in, to listen carefully, and to trust that narrative complexity is worth the effort. If you’re willing to become a sleuth for an evening, the reward is not only the satisfaction of solving the mystery, but the pleasure of watching a company commit to the intricate mechanics of Christie’s world and invite us to play along.
Kitty Goodall
Subscribe to our E-Newsletter, buy our latest print edition or find a Performing Arts book at Book Nook.